Do you make this call?

Live NLH tournement game...preflop minimum raise made by UTG followed by 4 callers including player immediately after UTG. Flop comes, UTG checks, next player bets pot, everyone folds except UTG who raises All-In. The player has top pair (A), nut flush draw and straight draw and has more than double the All-In's chip stack? All-In is a relatively tight player.

Does the player call?

__________________
Real poker players don't cry....

The FLOP determines how good your hole cards are!!

visit me at http://www.myspace.com/tzucanow

Hmm...If I worked it out right he may have a maximum of 14 outs (or less depending) If he's twice the allins stack I could see a call as being acceptable.

I'd find it hard to say what I'd of done really without knowing the stacks/blinds, stage of tourney and any info that the player may have on his opponent.
What was on the flop?

__________________
May/June '07
....Team: 7 Black Balls - Ballandchain, Blackinks & 7letters
.... Sunday League Team Champions

Nov/Dec '07
....Team: 7 Balls - Ballandchain & 7letters
....Sunday League Team Champions
....Sunday League Individual Runner Up - 7letters

Jan/Feb '08
....Sunday League Individual Runner Up - 7letters

March/April '08
....F'in rubbish - 7letters

June/July '08
....Midweek League
....Winner - 7letters

Tight player would make me fold , but otherwise I am a calling. Wait for my spot and a made hand that was the nuts. Looks like to many ways to lose in your description.

__________________
http://i227.photobucket.com/albums/d...arfromTess.gif
COW344

Blinds where 400/800. Player had 5200 chips and All-In had about 1900 chips. 6 players left. No money involved (just league points).

__________________
Real poker players don't cry....

The FLOP determines how good your hole cards are!!

visit me at http://www.myspace.com/tzucanow

top pair aces?? str8 draw, flush draw???
i would call,how could you not call,or did i read it wrong

__________________
THINK OUTSIDE THE FLOP

Well, the player (me) did call. I did because of my stack and I counted 15 outs (could be wrong). I saw a chance to knock a player out. He is a good friend btw and turned over a set (he had pocket 5's). Of course I hit one of my outs on the turn (nut flush), river didn't help him and he went ballistic. He has a low threshold for losing...lol. I won't hear the end of this for at least 2 months. I believed it to be a good call, but welcome others opinion.

__________________
Real poker players don't cry....

The FLOP determines how good your hole cards are!!

visit me at http://www.myspace.com/tzucanow

Thats a good call.

__________________


THFSOP Event #4 Champion
THFSOP Event #8 Champion
THFSOP Event #10 Champion

Current count: 3 Bracelets

Question on the other guys play... if he had 1900 in chips after the min raise to 1600 (3500 total). He has a little over 4BB in his stack... why not push preflop? The min raise commits him to his hand. With a premium pair (10's or better) this is a good time for a stop n go (pushing on any flop), but why do it with pocket 5's?
As for your call... it's a given. 15 real outs (probably more like 12-13 after discounting the outs) still makes it a coinflop even if he did flop the set.

__________________
Blackinks

Donkey Extraordinaire

"Never understimate the power of stupid people in large groups..." - Daryl "Razor" Reaugh

"I went in with the worst of it... and it held up!" - Alicia M

Well yeah I think at those blinds and he's going for a win, I think he can call . It looks like there's a 11K pot and he's calling about 2K? He's low if he folds and he's not out if he loses.

Not sure what the flop cards are but if his outs are good he can call.

Edit: Distracted whilst posting.
Hadn't seen the other replies but yeah that's a good point Blackinks.
So he had trips and lost I see. I think you did the right thing Cat and he shouldn't moan at you

__________________
May/June '07
....Team: 7 Black Balls - Ballandchain, Blackinks & 7letters
.... Sunday League Team Champions

Nov/Dec '07
....Team: 7 Balls - Ballandchain & 7letters
....Sunday League Team Champions
....Sunday League Individual Runner Up - 7letters

Jan/Feb '08
....Sunday League Individual Runner Up - 7letters

March/April '08
....F'in rubbish - 7letters

June/July '08
....Midweek League
....Winner - 7letters